• 2 min read
X and music publishers quietly end 3-year legal fight
X and major music publishers have agreed to dismiss their lawsuits with prejudice, ending a copyright dispute that began in 2023.
Image: ITzine
X and a group of major music publishers have agreed to drop the lawsuits they had been trading for nearly three years. Court filings do not disclose the terms, but both cases are being dismissed with prejudice, meaning neither side can bring the same claims again.
The dispute began in 2023, when a publisher group led by the National Music Publishers Association accused Twitter of widespread copyright infringement. According to the publishers, the platform allowed users to spread thousands of music clips with little friction and failed to build a clear system to protect rights holders. At the time, the claimed damages reached $250 million.
The case was particularly awkward for Twitter because it had long been one of the few major social platforms without a licensing agreement with music publishers. The argument was never just about individual tracks. It also centered on a broader issue: who pays, and how much, for music used across feeds, clips, and short-form video.
Recommended reading
Google Search adds free AI image creation
After Elon Musk bought Twitter and renamed it X, the legal battle continued. Nearly three years later, X filed a countersuit, arguing that publishers were using anticompetitive practices and effectively forcing platforms into licenses at inflated rates. That shifted the fight from simple copyright claims to a wider argument over the market power of rights holders.
That pattern is now common across the industry. Meta, TikTok, and YouTube have all faced recurring negotiations, complaints, and legal threats over music licensing. As recently as last month, X had asked the court to throw out the publishers' case, arguing that it should not be held responsible for user piracy.
Now both sides are walking away before any ruling on the merits. For X, that removes one of the most visible unresolved disputes inherited from the Twitter era. The bigger licensing question, though, remains expensive enough that it is unlikely to disappear from social media anytime soon.
Culture Editor
Maya explores gaming, streaming, and the internet as a place where people actually live. From deep-dives into creator economies to the anthropology of digital communities, she tracks platform drama and cultural shifts so you don't have to. She believes the best tech stories are fundamentally about human behavior.
via ITzine
